Tuesday, 10 July 2007

Karen Armstrong

I had read quite a few favourable reviews of Ms Armstrong so I really wanted to read her books, as it’s not everyday a non muslim gets favourable reviews for writing several books about Islam. The first one I’ve read is Muhammad (pbuh): A Biography of the Prophet. I was dubious about the front cover, it’s a bit ambiguous, at first I thought it was an image of the Prophet (pbuh) himself (which I’m sure is prohibited?), but on closer inspection the image has wings so perhaps it’s the Angel Gabriel?? Anyway to the book itself, I started it with gumption (that word has been in my mind for ages I really wanted to use it lol) it turned out that the book was a kind of response to the Satanic verses written by Salman Rushdie, a rectification of the downright rubbish that Rushdie had written about the prophet (pbuh). The first chapter is a short history of the hatred against Islam by the west starting from its earliest days to the present age, at first I found it interesting and the word applied to Muslims (Mohammedans) in the early days amused me. However it began to get repetitive and slightly boring, I was never one for history….. but once the book got back to the topic in hand, the book and the author redeemed themselves. One of the things I loved about the book was that, in discussing aspects of Islam the author also weaved in similarities between Islam, Christianity and Judaism, one of the things you never seem to see as much in books written by Muslim authors. Another thing which I found quite appealing was that the history and context of places is given before Islam touched the area, for example the history of medina post islam is given, which is rarely mentioned. However the author raised several points which really impressed me and will go far in clarifying Islam for non muslims, being mainly about the status of women in Islam and the idea that Islam is a “live by the sword, die by the sword” type of religion. I’m not going into detail here about it but will defiantly do a post regarding the points mentioned above. Overall I think the book is a brilliant asset to Islamic literature and I would happily read it over and over again. I definitely recommend everyone to read this book, muslims and non muslims alike

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

hey there!!! im a frend of mishys..n some how ended up on ure blog..so thought i might as well leave a comment while im here..ure blogs well cool lol plus....ure blog is sooooooooooooo much better than mishys in that its colourful and a lot more going on than hers..hehehe ive told her this already..but she insists on remaining plain jane!!! ahhh well thats mishy for ya!! anyway we have met b4 so im not a complete stranger invading ure blog lol

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the review! Insh'Allah I may check it out.

Atypical said...

hey anonymous, you're more than welcome to invade my blog anytime lol haha thanks for the compliments.. but on mishys behalf she has only had it for a few days whereas i've had it for a few months soo i suppose that could be a contributing reason...we have met before??..i shall ask mishy regarding you :)

Umm Yusuf: Inshalah you will :) i've also got another one of her books called a short history on islam i havn't read that yet but when i will i shall review it also!

Atypical said...

ok not a few days a few weeks.. i meant to say Mishy's only had it for a few weeks..before you go and have a go at me:P